FIA race director Charlie Whiting admits the governing body is struggling to find a solution to cure the problem of track limits.
For the second straight year, Austin's Circuit of the Americas provided a dilemma with drivers allowed to run wide at Turn 9 but not Turn 19 as well as sausage kerbs being installed in key areas such as Turn 15, 17 and 20.
Also like 2017, Max Verstappen was at the heart of track limits controversy with the extra kerb at T17 brought in after his incident with Kimi Raikkonen but then this year he broke his right-rear suspension on a sausage kerb exiting Turn 15 in qualifying.
“It [adding more kerbs] works better on some circuits than it does others,” Whiting commented.
“At the Red Bull Ring we had to put the additional kerbs behind, because the first time they were installed there were suspension failures. Basically, the cars couldn’t cope with the kerbs.
“You can see the problem there, some cars were OK, others weren’t but they had to redesign their cars to make sure that they can cope with the things.
“Adrian Newey came to me recently and suggested and we could have some sort of slippery kerb, and I said ‘that’s great Adrian, but if you can find a kerb that deters all kinds of car and is suitable for motorbikes, please tell me about it, because we can’t think of one at the moment'."
In Austin, the regulated track limits at Turn 19 extended until the outside of the kerb with a sensor installed while at other venues like Hockenheim the colour on the outside of the track is changed to signify where the limits are.
“This is one of the fundamental arguments that I have with them [the teams] sometimes,” Whiting continued. “They want the kerbs to be designed to suit the cars and I say ‘no, that’s not the way it is, you have to design the cars to suit the circuits’.
“It’s a complicated subject which is not simple to find a solution to.”
Another hurdle is finding solutions which are suitable for the various types of racing, open-wheel, GT, touring car etc. but by far the biggest is also incorporating motorbikes.
“I know that’s not our problem, but MotoGP want to run on some F1 circuits, World Superbikes do, and they need kerbs which don’t cause them too much difficulty,” Whiting added.
“This is whey we came up with the double kerb, as we call it, which is on the exit of Turns 9 and 19 [in Austin], and we’ve introduced it in a number of tracks now.
“We have kerbs that are just about good enough for F1 cars, they’re not enough to deter Porsche Supercup for example, but they’re OK for bikes, and that’s about a good a compromise as we’re going to get where you have a circuit that wants to run F1 and MotoGP.”
Whiting: Ocon 'wrong' to fight Verstappe
Raikkonen believes P3 the best he could
Ricciardo: 'Every time we start out of p
McLaren 'confident' Indy 500 plans won't
Red Bull call for Ocon race ban as Verst
Mercedes reveal Hamilton had 'failure im
Vettel gives Brazil race 'one out of ten
Hamilton tells Verstappen: 'You had more
Hamilton 'proud' of Mercedes as double c
Ocon claims Verstappen 'wanted to punch
Brazil GP: Hamilton inherits victory as
Ricciardo jokes 0.002s loss to Max 'more
Alonso & McLaren confirm Indy 500 return
Hamilton blasts 'disrespectful' Sirotkin
Vettel slams FIA weighbridge process aft
Brazil GP: Hamilton beats Vettel to pole
Brazil GP: Vettel sets new lap record in
Ferrari's Clear to have key Leclerc role
Hamilton says 25-race calendar would dri
'Realistic' Verstappen insists Red Bull
Red Bull reveal a Mexico marshal caused
Vettel expects Ferrari progress in Brazi
Williams offer Kubica 2019 seat but Ferr
Red Bull see race potential even if Braz
Brazil GP: Bottas pips Hamilton by 0.003
Brazil GP: Verstappen leads Vettel & Ham
Tyres and two-tier F1 to dominate driver
Verstappen: Mexico anger post-qualifying
Hamilton doubts Bottas would want F1 win
Alonso: McLaren optimistic 2019 car will
Ocon rejecting non-F1 offers to 'stay cl
Massa: Vettel 'more guilty' for 2018 tit
Hamilton to Leclerc & Gasly: 'No substit
Red Bull: 2019 front wings a costly 'sho
Sainz claims Schumacher name alone won't
Bottas: Hamilton's adaptability is his b
Force India: Signs point to Stroll being
Liberty want to 'preserve' classic F1 ra
Williams still getting over 'enormous sh
Hamilton doubts he would have recovered
Brazil step up security ahead of F1 race
Vietnam confirmed for 2020 F1 calendar
Studious Schumacher 'not as crazy' as Ve
Arrivabene: Ferrari still lack winning '
Ferrari CEO admits F1 budget cap 'makes
Mercedes target tyre woes and Constructo
Force India see catching F1's big three
Sainz has no issue with Renault over sig
Ferrari slam 'fake' Binotto rumours aime
Smedley confirms Williams departure afte
Sauber: Don't compare Leclerc to Hamilto
Two prospective manufacturers rule out F
Magnussen claims current cars leave F1 d
Red Bull: Immediate Gasly comparisons to
Vettel: 2018 Ferrari 'strong' but never
Webber fears Renault a threat to Ricciar
Hamilton: Bottas relationship as teammat
Magnussen: Haas should be 'proud' to be
Tombazis: FIA had to 'intervene' with 20
Zandvoort reportedly offered 2020 Dutch
Vettel wants himself & Leclerc to 'work
Mercedes: 'This is the best Lewis Hamilt
Ricciardo confirms participation in fina
Haas fail in bid to overturn Grosjean's
F1 bosses warn of 'step backwards' with
Hamilton believes Alonso made one crucia
Verstappen 'absolutely' ready as Red Bul
Hamilton: Monza victory a 'psychological
Horner: 'Only Daniel' Ricciardo knows of
Vettel 'past his peak' and lacks Ferrari
Mercedes praise Ferrari for 'gloves-off'
Hartley informed of Toro Rosso exit afte
Kubica to fill development role at Ferra
Verstappen's go after Ricciardo & Hamilt
Horner gives Renault rare credit after M
Hamilton could never consider himself Fo
Gasly questions Ocon's racing style afte
Mexico retirement 'hurts a lot' for Pere
Ericsson left 'fuming' after 'sacrificin
Vandoorne frustrated only points-scoring
Hamilton credits 'special moments' as ke
Bottas targets victory in Brazil & Abu D
Ecclestone: Formula 1 needs Hamilton 'mo
Vettel: Hockenheim crash not decisive in
Ricciardo doesn't 'see the point' in rac
Verstappen hails start for 'amazing' Mex
Mercedes boss Wolff had to compose himse
Vettel concedes Hamilton 'better' after
Hamilton 'humbled' by fifth Formula 1 ti
Mexico GP: Verstappen victorious as Hami
Hamilton wary of the 'red car behind' at
Vettel suggests Red Bull could 'beat the
Ricciardo elated, Verstappen deflated af
Mexico GP: Ricciardo beats Verstappen to
Mexico GP: Verstappen leads, Bottas hits
Vettel expecting 'big jumps' as teams un
Sainz doesn't see P3 as representative o
Hamilton uncertain of challenging Red Bu
Verstappen plays down practice stoppage
Bottas feels he could still be fighting